Earlier this week, in a cramped rental flat within the Bronx with a small Christmas tree, I had the privilege of chatting with one among Russia’s most esteemed musicians.
Mikhail Voskresensky is the previous head of the piano part on the celebrated Moscow Conservatory, the place Tchaikovsky was as soon as a professor. Now 87, he had assumed he would spend the remainder of his life in Moscow. His kids, grandchildren and great-grandchildren stay there. He nonetheless carried out often. And he had lived within the metropolis for many years, spanning the Stalinist period by means of perestroika to present president Vladimir Putin. “I by no means needed to depart,” he advised me.
However then Putin invaded Ukraine. Voskresensky is ethnically Russian, however was born in Berdyansk, Ukraine. Having witnessed German bombing as a small youngster and misplaced his father in fight, he hates warfare and thinks invading Ukraine “completely silly”. However when he shared his opposition along with his colleagues on the Conservatory, he was shocked to study that the majority both needed to remain silent — or supported it. “It was a wound to me, that clever, cultured individuals would assume that,” he stated. “That they had been brainwashed to assume that Russia itself was beneath assault from Nato.”
Within the spring he determined to flee — as some 700,000 different Russians have since February, based on Russian media experiences — and contacted pals on the Aspen Music Competition within the US to ask for an invite that would supply the prospect to defect.
A number of months handed earlier than he obtained the visa and Covid-19 vaccinations in place. All of the whereas, Voskresensky needed to preserve his plans secret from others, together with most of his household. However finally he, his spouse and their four-year-old son escaped and utilized for asylum. They’re now dwelling in New York Metropolis, hoping US immigration providers will grant Voskresensky permission to work.
The upheaval was big, and he was grief-stricken at forsaking his prolonged household, a few of whom, to his horror, denounced him. However he felt it was too harmful to remain. “Take a look at Ilya Yashin!” he stated, referring to the opposition politician sentenced to eight and a half years in jail final week for denouncing the warfare. It was a haunting second and, for me, underlined a degree typically ignored, particularly that — amid the Russian state’s brutality in the direction of Ukraine — there are a lot of courageous and respectable Russians.
It sounds apparent. However one ghastly consequence of Putin’s brutal marketing campaign is that it has sparked a wider revulsion in the direction of Russians and their tradition. Alan Fletcher, president of the Aspen Music Competition, is aware of this all too properly. When he first advised his colleagues that he needed to ask Voskresensky to America, “there was such a deep cut up [on the board] that we couldn’t even take a vote”, he stated. Some needed to ban all Russian artists and music, till Fletcher persuaded them in any other case
The Voskresensky saga additionally reveals widening splits in Russia’s intelligentsia. He’s definitely not the one artist against the warfare. Simply final week Vera Polozkova, a poet and actor dwelling abroad, known as Putin the “important maniac of the twenty first century”.
Voskresensky is aware of such protest is uncommon. Public life in Russia is dominated by more and more excessive nationalist rhetoric. (This week high TV hosts bantered about Russian troops invading London.) “I feel a majority of Russians don’t help the warfare in personal, however many individuals are afraid. I keep in mind the Stalin regime, when everybody was afraid to talk out, and it’s in our genetic code to be afraid of repression, jail and shedding our jobs. That modified in perestroika, and after. Now it’s again.”
That raises a last level: as refuseniks head for the exits, they could possibly be reshaping the Russian mental and artistic elite for years to come back. Within the quick time period, their loss is curbing inside opposition to Putin (with the notable exception of Alexei Navalny, the opposition chief, who’s being held in more and more squalid situations). In the long run, it additionally threatens to undermine future efforts to construct a civil society.
As Voskresensky identified, within the a long time because the Soviet Union collapsed, voters in Ukraine have steadily, albeit imperfectly, embraced a novel sense of company, a perception that they will exchange leaders they dislike. “I’ve pals there, so I’ve seen how individuals there have smelt democracy.” In Russia, in contrast, Putin’s warfare has undermined any sense of company amongst bizarre Russians, even because it has stoked it additional among the many Ukrainians.
That is tragic for Russia and has had extra horrific penalties for Ukrainians. However even at his superior age, Voskresensky hopes that sometime he’ll have the ability to go house. “I can’t whereas Putin is there, however who is aware of?”
Observe Gillian on Twitter @gilliantett and e-mail her at [email protected]
Observe @FTMag on Twitter to seek out out about our newest tales first
